Ryan Widmer, a 27 year old man, was charged with murder just 2 days after he found his wife unresponsive in their bathtub, on August 11, 2008. Ryan was downstairs watching TV, when his wife of only 114 days kissed him goodnight and told him she was going upstairs to take a bath. This was part of Sarah Widmer’s regular routine as she loved to take long baths. Ryan went upstairs about ½ hour to 45 minutes later to walk into their bathroom and find Sarah unresponsive in the tub. Ryan tried as best he could to perform CPR. The 911 operator didn’t provide any help whatsoever.
After 45 minutes to 1 hour of rigorous CPR and 5 intubation attempts they transported Sarah to the hospital and she was pronounced dead. There were no signs of struggle, no prior history of relationship issues, etc. However, Sarah had not been feeling well the entire day and had a bad headache. She was also known by family and friends to easily fall asleep and had actually fallen asleep in the tub numerous times, even before she met Ryan (as stated by Sarah’s brother). An expert at the trial spoke that in the U.S. every year about 300,000 people under the age of 35 die and that these people’s autopsies do not show any sign of what they died from - a staggering statistic.
Continue Reading Ryan and Sarah's Story
Prosecution |
Defense |
|
1. Prosecutors claim Ryan held Sarah by the neck and forcibly drowned her during an altercation and cleaned up the scene before calling 911. |
1. Neither Ryan nor Sarah had any marks or wounds on their bodies and there were no signs of a struggle. A search of the house showed no evidence of a cleanup. Sarah's French Manicure and Pedicure were still perfect. |
|
2. Because of the two blood spots on the carpet, prosecutors said Ryan moved Sarah's body before calling 911. |
2. Officer Bishop testified he might have helped Ryan move Sarah's body from the bathroom doorway into the bedroom. (1st Trial) He couldn't remember if he helped move Sarah. (2nd Trial) He "absolutely did not" help Ryan move her body. (3rd Trial). |
|
3. Ryan allegedly confessed to Jennifer Crew that he punched Sarah in the chest during an argument and then blacked out. When he came to, she was laying dead on the bathroom floor. He said he forgot to clean up the spilled waste basket in the bathroom. |
3. Jennifer Crew has a criminal record and is a recovering drug addict now on methadone, who saw Ryan's story on Dateline. Most of her testimony, word for word, was from the Dateline program. Officer Bishop dumped the bathroom trash can looking for illegal drugs. (1st & 2nd trial) He didn’t remember dumping it, but agreed that he's been blamed for it. (3rd Trial). |
|
4. The lead detective (Braley) and the coroner's investigator were present during the autopsy and discussed with the coroner what the manner of death might be. Det. Braley gathered evidence and dusted the tub for fingerprints claiming streaks on the tub showed signs of Sarah trying to save herself. |
4. The coroner was criticized in another trial for allowing investigating officers to name the manner of death. Braley was not a trained evidence technician and criminalist Wm. Hilliard said none of the fingerprints were of any value. He couldn't tell who they belonged to or when they were put on the tub. Braley was forced to resign when it was verified that he lied on his employment application and didn't have the training or experience that he claimed. |
|
5. First responders testified that Sarah's body, the tub, towels, clothing, magazines, floor, etc. were all dry. |
5. Officers and EMTs wore gloves when feeling for wetness. Signs of water in the tub included droplets on the drain and a small area of water pooled near the middle of the tub. Some officers admitted they didn't touch anything to feel for wetness. Magazines were crinkled, indicating they had been wet. Two EMTs testified that Sarah's body was moist or not overly wet. Officer Bishop noticed an Ionic Breeze fan knocked over near where Sarah was lying. (1st Trial) The dryer was cold, indicating that it had not been used. |
|
6. Coroner Uptegrove declared Sarah's death a homicide before reading the EMT and ER reports, and without talking to Ryan or Sarah's mother about any health issues. |
6. The coroner spoke briefly with Sarah's mother after Ryan had already been charged, arrested and arraigned. He never did speak to Ryan and was not told that she frequently fell asleep in the tub. Her mother and brother knew she fell asleep in the tub. There were numerous mistakes on the run report, as well as three different copies. |
|
7. The coroner made his decision based on the bruising on the side and back of her neck. He said there was no evidence of any heart problem or seizure. |
7. EMTs tried to intubate Sarah twice in the house, once while the ambulance was in the driveway and two more times while en route to the hospital. An EMT assisted twice by performing the Sellick maneuver. He held Sarah's head and neck firmly while applying pressure at the thyroid cartilage. EMTs worked on Sarah for almost 45 minutes before leaving for the hospital. Doctors testified that 5 intubations would cause neck bruising and in a drowning, the blood is thinner and bruising would spread farther. Forensic pathologist Dr. Balko testified coroner Uptegrove didn't take enough heart or brain tissue samples to verify there was no heart problem or seizure and didn't test for narcolepsy. Coroner Uptegrove has been criticized for taking short cuts and having a coroner's job in three counties. |
|
8. Sarah's mother said Sarah was always healthy, had no history of heart problems and there was no history of heart problems or seizures in the family. She didn't recall Sarah ever falling asleep anywhere. |
8. In the 3rd trial, she admitted that Sarah had surgery for a cleft palate and had a heart murmur as an infant. She took Sarah to a pediatric cardiologist but never followed up over the years. |
|
9. In the 2nd trial Sarah's mother said, they're part of a younger generation and talk differently to each other. She said, "They would argue on certain things. They got in an argument on how to hang pictures so they called Sarah's brother to come and hang all the pictures in their house. In the 3rd trial she said they called each other "nasty names". |
9. In previous trials she testified that Ryan and Sarah got along well together and they were very happy. They bought a house and moved in together and Ryan became part of their family even before they married. When asked what the "nasty names" were, she couldn't say. |

| Defense Witness: Dana Parker-Kist |
| Written by Mike Mayleben |
| Friday, 06 May 2011 18:26 |
|
Direct Exam: Lindsey Gutierrez She lives in Alexandria, Ky., and is now a registered nurse. Prior to that position, she was employed as a receptionist for Dr. Becker in Ft. Thomas, Ky. and helped Sarah get the job with Dr. Becker through a mutual friend. She met Ryan through her husband Chris Kist, who met Ryan in college and roomed with him. "She was one of the best people this world has ever known," Dana said of Sarah. "She was more than what I can say as far as a friend," she added, as she began to cry. "She was very spunky and fun; she never really met a stranger, she was an open book." She leaned her head down to cry, talking about her friend. The Judge asked if she needed a moment, she raised her head and apologized. She went on to say that she and her husband introduced Sarah and Ryan. They double-dated and got along very well. Ryan and Sarah made plans for a second date the day of their first date. She said Sarah pulled out her black book to pencil him in, and they later discovered she didn't have anything else written in the book. They double-dated a lot with Ryan and Sarah and they seemed very happy, "they complimented each other." She said she never saw Ryan and Sarah get mad at each other--she only remembered a disagreement about the color of paint in their house. "Ryan and my husband picked out a paint color without Sarah's and my input-- not a good idea," she said with a laugh. She was a bridesmaid in Sarah and Ryan's wedding and she helped organize a bridal shower at the dentist's office. After she left Dr. Becker's practice she said they still met for lunch and talked on the phone at least once a week. "We shared a lot with each other" she said. Sarah told her about her health concerns, like headaches, and seeing blurry spots with the headache. She was teased a lot about her falling sleeping habit. She offered Tylenol and encouraged her to see a doctor. She knew of a doctor appointment Sarah had but didn't know when. She didn't know if Sarah saw a doctor on a regular basis. Sarah never complained about any financial or marital issues to her, she said. The last time she talked to Sarah was late July or early August of 2008. She [Dana] took a trip in early August and was supposed to meet with Sarah when she returned, but she never did... her voice trembled. When she worked with Sarah, she would find her sleeping in the car before work, and she would knock on the window to wake her up. Sarah also slept during her lunch hour sometimes, and when Sarah came to her house to hang out, she would end up staying overnight because she was too sleepy to drive home or had fallen asleep while they were watching a movie. Gutierrez showed Dana a photo from her baby shower. It showed Dana seated to the left with a box of Huggies diapers. Sarah was on the right, writing gifts in a notebook. Her name tag said "sleeper." They played a game and everyone had name tags that were baby items, she explained. "It was kind of a play on words because of Sarah’s sleeping habits that we joked about", she said. She was interviewed by officers at Dr. Becker's office. She didn't work there anymore; she just happened to be there. She didn't recall investigators asking about Sarah's sleeping habits or her medical issues. They were asking about Ryan, mostly. When police questioned her about Ryan, she told them that Ryan never had any anger issues or drinking issues. She said she remembered a couple times when Sarah had to sit in a dark room because of a bad headache. Nothing further. Cross Exam: Travis Vieux She met Ryan in 2002, while they were in college. He was her husband's roommate and they've been friends for about 9 years. After knowing Sarah for about 2 months, they set her up with Ryan. She had known Ryan for about 5 years at that time. She said she testified at the two previous trials. She and Sarah would eat lunch together often, but they only worked together two days a week. She said Sarah never fell asleep during their lunches. After she left Dr. Becker's office, they saw each other less but talked on the phone regularly. That's when she had her first baby. She could only remember Sarah sitting in the dark room twice, and it never affected her work or caused her to reschedule a patient. She hasn’t had any special training in cardiology or neurology, but as a registered nurse, she knew that headaches were a common complaint. It didn't make her any less concerned as a friend. She knew Sarah had sinus trouble but didn't know if she took medicine for it. Asked if Sarah had two physicals while they knew each other, she could only recall one. She recommended Sarah see a doctor before her April 2008 wedding and found out at the other two trials that she had an appointment in June 2008 when the doctor didn't find anything wrong. She worked with Sarah when her father was sick and passed away, and saw the stress it put on her. He was sick for a long time. She said Sarah would still talk about her dad occasionally after his death and she took on additional responsibilities in her family, caring for her mother after her father died. She said Sarah was "very organized" when planning the wedding. She acknowledged Sarah was stressed, but it was a "good stress." "I think she enjoyed it," she said. She was not in the Widmer home the night Sarah died. Nothing further. |